International concern grows as hundreds die in Egypt
By Andre Mayer, CBC News
Posted: Aug 15, 2013 7:53 PM ET
Last Updated: Aug 16, 2013 10:02 AM ET
While the deadly violence in Egypt has brought denunciations from many world leaders, experts say the country’s stature in the Middle East and the sheer rancour of its internal politics make any outside involvement a remote possibility.
“I’m afraid there’s no such thing as foreign intervention in Egypt to establish peace,” says Houchang Hassan-Yari, a professor in the Centre for International and Defence Policy at Queen’s University.
The current protests are a response to the events of July 3, when the Egyptian military deposed democratically elected president Mohammed Morsi, who heads the Muslim Brotherhood party.
Clashes between supporters of the Muslim Brotherhood and members of the interim military government have escalated in recent weeks. At least 638 people have died in the last couple of days according to Egypt's Health Ministry; the Muslim Brotherhood says it is closer to 2,600.
The current protests are a response to the events of July 3, when the Egyptian military deposed democratically elected president Mohammed Morsi, who heads the Muslim Brotherhood party.
Clashes between supporters of the Muslim Brotherhood and members of the interim military government have escalated in recent weeks. At least 638 people have died in the last couple of days according to Egypt's Health Ministry; the Muslim Brotherhood says it is closer to 2,600.
Obama condemns military crackdown
U.S. President Barack Obama has announced that in light of the crisis in Egypt, he is cancelling joint U.S.-Egyptmilitary exercises next month. (Larry Downing/Reuters)
On Thursday, U.S. President Barack Obama said the U.S. “strongly condemns the steps taken by Egypt’s military” in recent days and announced that he was cancelling joint U.S.-Egypt military exercises next month.
Canada’s Foreign Minister John Baird has also voiced his concern over the violence, saying the military and the Muslim Brotherhood “must immediately sit down together, reconcile their differences and work tirelessly to halt this deadly standoff.”
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, a Morsi ally, went a step further, agitating for a meeting of the United Nations Security Council to discuss the crisis, which took place Thursday night. The security council called for national reconciliation in Egypt.
Egypt is the world’s most populous Arab country and the cultural heart of the Middle East, and its stability is highly important to the region as a whole, says Hassan-Yari.
Although there is much talk about the potential of foreign intervention, outside countries “are involved in this conflict, and have been involved in this conflict, from the beginning,” says Jacob Shapiro, a Middle East analyst for global intelligence firm Stratfor.
U.S. President Barack Obama has announced that in light of the crisis in Egypt, he is cancelling joint U.S.-Egyptmilitary exercises next month. (Larry Downing/Reuters)
On Thursday, U.S. President Barack Obama said the U.S. “strongly condemns the steps taken by Egypt’s military” in recent days and announced that he was cancelling joint U.S.-Egypt military exercises next month.
Canada’s Foreign Minister John Baird has also voiced his concern over the violence, saying the military and the Muslim Brotherhood “must immediately sit down together, reconcile their differences and work tirelessly to halt this deadly standoff.”
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, a Morsi ally, went a step further, agitating for a meeting of the United Nations Security Council to discuss the crisis, which took place Thursday night. The security council called for national reconciliation in Egypt.
Egypt is the world’s most populous Arab country and the cultural heart of the Middle East, and its stability is highly important to the region as a whole, says Hassan-Yari.
Although there is much talk about the potential of foreign intervention, outside countries “are involved in this conflict, and have been involved in this conflict, from the beginning,” says Jacob Shapiro, a Middle East analyst for global intelligence firm Stratfor.
Behind-the-scenes involvement
Shapiro says this involvement has been largely behind the scenes, and skewed to the different factions. For the brief period when Morsi and the Muslim Brotherhood were in power, countries such as Turkey and Qatar provided aid and diplomatic support.
At least 638 people were killed in a recent security crackdown on the Muslim Brotherhood movement, which has left the most populous Arab nation polarized and in turmoil. (Mohamed Abd El Ghany/Reuters)
As soon as Morsi was deposed, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates came through with billions in aid for the interim military government, says Shapiro.
He argues that most Arab countries, as well as the U.S., are pro-military and would prefer Egypt remain out of the hands of an Islamist government.
Shapiro says that while some U.S. officials, such as senators John McCain and Lindsey Graham, have visited Cairo, it's unlikely to lead to sustained peacemaking efforts. "If you’re talking about any meaningful escalation [of diplomacy], I don’t see that," he says.
The region is also divided. In addition to Turkey, Islamists are in power in Tunisia to the west and Sudan to the south.
Tunisian President Rachid Ghannouchi sent a message today "to our brothers and sisters in Egypt" that says, "you will defeat dictatorship and your peaceful struggle will defeat blood and bullets." But he called on Brotherhood supporters not to react with violence.
Hassan-Yari says other nearby countries are either fearful of greater Islamist influence in the region (Saudi Arabia, UAE), or are too small or fractured to have much say in the affairs of other countries (Jordan, Syria).
Shapiro says this involvement has been largely behind the scenes, and skewed to the different factions. For the brief period when Morsi and the Muslim Brotherhood were in power, countries such as Turkey and Qatar provided aid and diplomatic support.
At least 638 people were killed in a recent security crackdown on the Muslim Brotherhood movement, which has left the most populous Arab nation polarized and in turmoil. (Mohamed Abd El Ghany/Reuters)
As soon as Morsi was deposed, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates came through with billions in aid for the interim military government, says Shapiro.
He argues that most Arab countries, as well as the U.S., are pro-military and would prefer Egypt remain out of the hands of an Islamist government.
Shapiro says that while some U.S. officials, such as senators John McCain and Lindsey Graham, have visited Cairo, it's unlikely to lead to sustained peacemaking efforts. "If you’re talking about any meaningful escalation [of diplomacy], I don’t see that," he says.
The region is also divided. In addition to Turkey, Islamists are in power in Tunisia to the west and Sudan to the south.
Tunisian President Rachid Ghannouchi sent a message today "to our brothers and sisters in Egypt" that says, "you will defeat dictatorship and your peaceful struggle will defeat blood and bullets." But he called on Brotherhood supporters not to react with violence.
Hassan-Yari says other nearby countries are either fearful of greater Islamist influence in the region (Saudi Arabia, UAE), or are too small or fractured to have much say in the affairs of other countries (Jordan, Syria).
Calling a coup a coup
In appealing to the UN, Turkey’s Erdogan berated Western powers for ignoring the bloodshed.
“Those who ignore the coup and don't even display the honourable behaviour of calling a coup a coup, share in the guilt of the massacre of those children,” he said.
Turkish Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan has called on the UN Security Council to convene quickly and act after what he described as a massacre in Egypt. (Umit Bektas/Reuters)
Erdogan’s comment was a none-too-subtle shot at the U.S., which has not called Morsi’s ouster a coup. The Americans would run afoul of U.S. law, if they provide military aid “to the government of any country whose duly elected head of government is deposed by military coup d'etat or decree."
While some commentators have criticized Obama for not punishing the Egyptian military, others say the U.S. is in a tricky position.
“Alienating the Egyptians one way or the other is very difficult, which is why I think they are very prudent in Washington,” says Hassan-Yari. “[The Americans] don’t have the liberty and the freedom to basically condemn or suspend any relations.”
Some commentators say that by revoking $1.5 billion in military aid, the U.S. would send a strong message to the Egyptians. But it could hurt the U.S. even more, says Mohammad Fadel, a Middle East expert in theUniversity of Toronto’s faculty of law. He says the aid to Egypt is “basically a subsidy to U.S. military contractors.”
He doesn’t believe that the money matters much to the Egyptian government, anyway.
“It’s too small an amount to make any difference to the calculations of the Egyptian military,” says Fadel. “They got 12 billion on Day 1 of the coup from the Gulf countries.”
In appealing to the UN, Turkey’s Erdogan berated Western powers for ignoring the bloodshed.
“Those who ignore the coup and don't even display the honourable behaviour of calling a coup a coup, share in the guilt of the massacre of those children,” he said.
Turkish Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan has called on the UN Security Council to convene quickly and act after what he described as a massacre in Egypt. (Umit Bektas/Reuters)
Erdogan’s comment was a none-too-subtle shot at the U.S., which has not called Morsi’s ouster a coup. The Americans would run afoul of U.S. law, if they provide military aid “to the government of any country whose duly elected head of government is deposed by military coup d'etat or decree."
While some commentators have criticized Obama for not punishing the Egyptian military, others say the U.S. is in a tricky position.
“Alienating the Egyptians one way or the other is very difficult, which is why I think they are very prudent in Washington,” says Hassan-Yari. “[The Americans] don’t have the liberty and the freedom to basically condemn or suspend any relations.”
Some commentators say that by revoking $1.5 billion in military aid, the U.S. would send a strong message to the Egyptians. But it could hurt the U.S. even more, says Mohammad Fadel, a Middle East expert in theUniversity of Toronto’s faculty of law. He says the aid to Egypt is “basically a subsidy to U.S. military contractors.”
He doesn’t believe that the money matters much to the Egyptian government, anyway.
“It’s too small an amount to make any difference to the calculations of the Egyptian military,” says Fadel. “They got 12 billion on Day 1 of the coup from the Gulf countries.”
No compromise in sight
The clashes in recent weeks are a manifestation of the deep divisions between the Muslim Brotherhood and the interim military government, says Hassan-Yari.
The Brotherhood says the only acceptable solution to the current violence is the reinstatement of Morsi as president. For the Egyptian army, however, “that chapter is closed,” Hassan-Yari argues.
The military has said that during his time in office, Morsi was unable to improve the economy or unite Egyptians, and that going forward, the country must review the constitution before proceeding to another round of parliamentary and presidential elections.
Because of these deep philosophical divisions, it is unlikely that any outside power can exercise much sway, says Hassan-Yari.
In lieu of any productive foreign involvement, there has been rampant speculation that the situation could devolve into civil war. Fadel says it’s unlikely, because the Muslim Brotherhood cannot match the military in terms of firepower.
“What I think is very likely is endemic civil strife, endemic oppression — the kind of dirty war that you saw in Latin America in the ‘70s. I think that’s where Egypt is going.”
- Policemen stand guard inside a room of the al-Fath mosque after supporters of deposed Egyptian President Mohamed Mursi opened fire on security forces from a second floor window in the Fath mosque, where hundreds of Mursi supporters have been taking refuge since protests turned violent on Friday. (Muhammad Hamed/Reuters)
The clashes in recent weeks are a manifestation of the deep divisions between the Muslim Brotherhood and the interim military government, says Hassan-Yari.
The Brotherhood says the only acceptable solution to the current violence is the reinstatement of Morsi as president. For the Egyptian army, however, “that chapter is closed,” Hassan-Yari argues.
The military has said that during his time in office, Morsi was unable to improve the economy or unite Egyptians, and that going forward, the country must review the constitution before proceeding to another round of parliamentary and presidential elections.
Because of these deep philosophical divisions, it is unlikely that any outside power can exercise much sway, says Hassan-Yari.
In lieu of any productive foreign involvement, there has been rampant speculation that the situation could devolve into civil war. Fadel says it’s unlikely, because the Muslim Brotherhood cannot match the military in terms of firepower.
“What I think is very likely is endemic civil strife, endemic oppression — the kind of dirty war that you saw in Latin America in the ‘70s. I think that’s where Egypt is going.”
- Policemen stand guard inside a room of the al-Fath mosque after supporters of deposed Egyptian President Mohamed Mursi opened fire on security forces from a second floor window in the Fath mosque, where hundreds of Mursi supporters have been taking refuge since protests turned violent on Friday. (Muhammad Hamed/Reuters)
No comments:
Post a Comment